Solitary by Necessity

stan-moody-solitary-confinement

By definition writing fiction must be a solitary affair. When it comes to non-fiction, collaboration between writers is possible, often highly desirable. In this case two heads are better than one when it comes to the necessary amount of research required; whereas the very idea of attempting to co-write a work of fiction with another writer leaves much to be desired. It only ever works in the arenas of film and television where a team of script writers brainstorm and throw ideas for specific situations into the mix.

Why could it never work with writing fictional books? Could it simply be down to a clash of personalities? I don’t think so; I believe it goes much deeper than that. Any writer of fiction worth their salt will tell you that coming up with that fresh storyline is akin to bringing a new-born into the world. It first appears as a vague notion in your mind which slowly develops as time goes by. As you begin writing, it gradually advances from the embryo stage. Like any prospective parent you jealously guard and nurture it as it grows. So the very idea of sharing that idea with another writer, expecting them to feel that same way about it, let alone using your ‘voice’ because you are the originator, simply does not compute. The idea is yours and yours alone. Therefore you must always be the one to see it through to completion.

As far as books go there is only one area in fiction writing where any form of collaboration appears to work successfully, and that is in the field of short story anthologies. But even then each tale is written by a solitary writer, so it’s still not true collaboration.

Having said all this, I do know of one recent example where two fiction writers worked on one project together. Whether or not their brave, some might say foolish, decision to collaborate will be justified is now down to the reading public’s acceptance of the book in question. After all, as writers we are all aware of just how fickle, nay contrary, the reading public can be at times.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Solitary by Necessity

  1. That’s very true, Jack. Those notions spawned by your mind are your children – they are noetic representations of your soul. And only they can endure the test of time, after death claims us all. Collaboration on non-fiction is a great thing. Collaboration on non-fiction is quite hard. I wouldn’t want to pollute the dream weaving of others, nor would I like them to pollute mine. That’s just how it is. It reminds of why George RR Martin said that he hated fan fictions of his works. The idea of strangers using his mythos and his characters was something he hated. And while I understand how much of a compliment that is – people loving so much his creations, than they take the time to write fan fiction – I have to completely agree with RR Martin on his sentiments.

    Like

  2. I hope to prove you wrong Jack. 🙂

    Myself and five other authors have just finished a collaborative fiction novel, and it is now in the editing stages and will be released this year. It was fun to do, even exciting at times, as we all dug in with our ideas. It is to be called ‘Isabella: Captured Souls’. Hope you check it out when we release it 🙂

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s